Texas Border Wire Case Is Far From Over

Battle between Texas & Federal Government

But temporary decision is really just the beginning of the court fight Washington, D.C. (January 25, 2024) – A Center for Immigration Studies analysis highlights this week's Supreme Court order vacating an injunction imposed by the Fifth Circuit in DHS v. Texas. The case, brought by the state of Texas, sought to stop Biden's CBP from destroying portions of a 29-mile section of concertina-wire ("c-wire") barriers erected by the state along the Rio Grande to deter illegal migrants. Two of the Court's conservatives — Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Amy Coney Barrett — joined the three liberal justices in that decision, but their order hardly settles the matter. In fact, given the unresolved factual and legal issues in this case, it's really just begun. "Texas's legal effort to stop Biden's CBP from destroying its property is far from over," said Andrew Arthur, the Center's fellow in law and policy and author of the analysis. "It will now go back to the Fifth Circuit to address Texas's legal arguments in full." This conflict over whether the federal government or Texas is responsible for the enforcement of the border began in March 2021, when Texas Gov. Greg Abbott launched "Operation Lone Star," a state effort to respond to the massive wave of migrants pouring across the border unleashed by Joe Biden's reversal of his predecessor's successful border deterrence policies. Under the initiative, Texas deployed state troopers and National Guard troops to monitor and respond to illegal border crossings. It came to a head with the end of Title 42 on May 11, when the Texas Department of Public Safety (DPS) and Texas Military Department (TMD) began installing concertina wire barriers on the Texas side of the river to prevent smugglers and illegal entrants from crossing into populated areas where they could disappear before arrest. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) was apparently grateful for the help, except along 29 miles of the border in Maverick County, where agents began removing the c-wire in September, encouraging migrants to enter the country. The case has been making its way through the courts ever since. Texas State Attorney General Ken Paxton issued a statement in response to the SCOTUS ruling, characterizing the Court's order as "temporary" and stating, "The destruction of Texas's border barriers will not help enforce the law or keep American citizens safe. This fight is not over, and I look forward to defending our state's sovereignty." Arthur commented, "There are a lot of news cameras on the border; every time CBP rips out that wire, it will be seen by the public, and show voters how little interest the Biden administration has in enforcing the law."

New from the Center for Immigration Studies, 1/30/24

Report Immigration-Related Regulatory Proposals Expected in 2024 By Elizabeth Jacobs, January 24, 2024 Excerpt: As we enter the fourth year of the Biden administration, CIS expects immigration policy-makers to continue their aggressive regulatory agenda. This report discusses the regulatory changes that the Biden administration has indicated it intends to make in 2024 related to the Department of Homeland Security, Department of Justice, Department of Labor, and Department of Health and Human Services.  Commentary Biden's Border Chutzpah By Mark Krikorian Compact, January 29, 2024 Excerpt: But before addressing the shortcomings of a possible deal, we need to step back and ask a more basic question: Why does Congress need to act at all? The border crisis is entirely President Biden's doing. It is an executive problem, not a legislative one, and requires a change in the administration's policies, not new laws. More Biden Recklessness: Bombing Houthi Jihadists While Keeping Our Borders Wide Open By Philip Linderman The American Conservative, January 23, 2024 Excerpt: More than two decades after 9/11, the Washington national-security establishment is again focused on our overseas posture rather than the homeland. The Road from Damascus By Todd Bensman The American Mind, January 22, 2024 Excerpt: Syrians pose an overlooked security threat for Europe, one worth American attention too: 538 of them were counted at the U.S.-Mexico border, which is facing its own historically unprecedented mass migration crisis. Will Mass Migration Breach Poland's Famous Border Fence? By Todd Bensman The National Interest, January 19, 2024 Excerpt: A recent shift from the political Right to Left in Poland's national government now threatens those two-plus years of tranquility in Kuznica and all along Poland's now-famed steel fence—widely credited as emblematic of how walls stop illegal immigration.   Podcast Panel Podcast: Asylum in the U.S. and Europe Host: Mark Krikorian Guests: Viktor Marsai, Director of the Budapest-based Migration Research Institute Nicolas Pouvreau-Monti, Co-founder of the Immigration and Demography Observatory in France Eric Ruark, Director of Research at NumbersUSA Parsing Immigration Policy, Episode 139 Featured Posts Immigration Tops Voters' Concerns in Latest Poll, as Approval of President's Handling Plummets By Andrew R. Arthur Excerpt: For the first time in my recollection, "immigration" now tops the list of the most important issues facing the country today in the opinion of voters, jumping seven points in a month and overtaking "inflation", according to the latest Harvard/Harris poll. Don't Believe the Hype — Securing the Border's Not That Hard By Andrew R. Arthur Excerpt: The price tag for detention would be high at first, but those costs would diminish quickly once would-be migrants find out illegal entry is no longer a "free ticket" into the United States. UN Budgets Millions for U.S.-Bound Migrants in 2024 By Todd Bensman Excerpt: A December update to the UN's "Regional Refugee and Migrant Response Plan" outlines plans to distribute hundreds of millions of dollars to migrants in Latin America making their way north to illegally cross the U.S. border. During Human Trafficking Prevention Month, CIS Sues HHS for UAC Records By Colin Farnsworth Excerpt: Many aspects of Unaccompanied Children program have been shrouded in secrecy, leaving state and local officials unaware of potential problems within their jurisdictions, and shielding HHS and its contractors from accountability. More Blog Posts Bizarre Conspiracy: Aliens Claim Green Cards Because They'd Been Abused by Their Citizen Children Senate Border Proposals Would Do Nothing to Secure the Border Texas Gov. Sends Border Warning to White House Recent Immigration Could Not Have Reduced Inflation Significantly CBP Border Numbers Released: December Was Officially the Worst Month in History The Latest Development in the Long-Running Mayorkas/Edwards Feud Andrew R. Arthur, resident fellow in law and policy for the Center, speaks with LiveNOW from FOX about SCOTUS' decision to allow Border Patrol agents to cut concertina wire that Texas had installed along the border near Eagle Pass.